There is a story in the Sydney Morning Herald today about Titanium Asset Management - a funds manager in Western Sydney that operates as part of the Titanium Financial Group.
Titanium has been on my must-look-at list for some time. I found them when researching Astarra/Trio - a funds management fraud shown to me by one of my readers which I reported to the regulatory authorities. Titaninum had agreed a white-label deal distribution deal with Astarra, a deal which to the best of my knowledge was never consumated with real money. Titanium said that there was no relationship with Astarra but one Titanium entity wound up in the hands of the Astarra/Trio liquidators. [Someone has suggested in the comments that the Titanium entity in the hands of the Astarra/Trio liquidators is not related to the Titanium financial planners and that no money ever changed hands with the agreed white-label deal linked above. I see no reason to disbelieve that - especially as the article is dated within a month of the demise of Astarra/Trio.]
What amazed me though was the returns of Titanium Asset Management. It was limited according to its documents to being long-short the stocks in the ASX200 (an index of the top 200 companies in Australia). These were the monthly returns as reported:
These returns are astounding. 40 percent in October 2008, 20 percent in February 2009. Magic numbers really.
So I rang the fund manager - Peter Rice - to try and work out how he did it. I did not understand - at least it did not make sense to me so I reported my concerns to ASIC.
I did make an effort though. I found an interview with Peter Rice on Sky News (repeated below). That made no sense either.
Anyway I put it out of my mind.
A couple of weeks ago I looked again. Here are later returns.
The early months had all gone. (No more 40 percent months!)
The return in February 2009 had gone from plus 20 percent to minus 7 percent.
I was puzzled.
I rang the auditor as listed in the original product disclosure status. He sounded sorry for me - wondering if I was an investor in the fund. He told me he had never been the auditor and had gone to some lengths to let the regulator know that he was falsely listed as the auditor.
I rang Peter Rice and he told me the original returns came from "paper trading". I wondered why he did not tell me that the first time I rang and he said that he did not believe he was under an obligation to disclose that. (Indeed when I rang him the first time he told me that he had an independent back office and used Citigroup as his prime broker - both things that would not occur if the profits were from paper trading.)
I sent it all to the Sydney Morning Herald. (My job is to manage money - not explore these things...)
I think Michael West did a great job of the story.
He also pointed out something that truly surprised me. Andrew Blanchette who controls Titanium (at least is listed on the license and is the owner of the domain names) was once the boyfriend of Sydney model Caroline Byrne. She was found dead at the bottom of Sydney suicide spot The Gap. Maybe suicide. Maybe murder.
Caroline's death was the subject of much gossip in Sydney - the prime suspect was Gordon Wood. Wood was Caroline's boyfriend at the time of her death and was also the chauffeur to Rene Rivkin a colourful Sydney stockbroker. Rivkin has since committed suicide.
Wood was convicted but since then Australia's highest profile current affairs program has thrown that conviction into doubt.
This mostly proves that Sydney is sometimes a very small town. No more.
Saturday, February 18, 2012
Posted by John Hempton at 12:06 PM
The content contained in this blog represents the opinions of Mr. Hempton. Mr. Hempton may hold either long or short positions in securities of various companies discussed in the blog based upon Mr. Hempton's recommendations. The commentary in this blog in no way constitutes a solicitation of business or investment advice. In fact, it should not be relied upon in making investment decisions, ever. It is intended solely for the entertainment of the reader, and the author. In particular this blog is not directed for investment purposes at US Persons.